Château Les Carmes Haut-Brion

RVI 100 Vinous – A. Galloni 100 Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 100 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 99 - 100 Alexandre Ma 99 J. Suckling 99 J.M. Quarin 99 Terre de Vins 98 - 99 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 97-99 Decanter 98 Jeb Dunnuck 98 Le Figaro 96 - 98 Vinous – N. Martin 96-98 Bettane & Desseauve 96 - 97 Jane Anson 96 RVF 94 - 96 Jancis Robinson 17

Le Figaro 96 - 99 Terre de Vins 98 Vinous – A. Galloni 98 Anthocyanes - Y. Castaing 96-98 Alexandre Ma 97 J.M. Quarin 97 J. Suckling 96-97 Decanter 96 Bettane & Desseauve 95 - 96 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 94 - 96 Vinous – N. Martin 95 Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 95 Jeb Dunnuck 93 - 95 RVF 93 - 95 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 93-95+ Jane Anson 94 Jancis Robinson 17++

Anthocyanes - Y. Castaing 99-100 Jeb Dunnuck 98 Terre de Vins 98 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 98+ Alexandre Ma 97 J. Suckling 97 J.M. Quarin 97 Vinous – A. Galloni 97+ Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 96 Vinous – N. Martin 95 Decanter 94 Wine spec 92 Jancis Robinson 16

Vinous – A. Galloni 100 Anthocyanes - Y. Castaing 98-100 Terre de Vins 98 Le Figaro 97 - 98 Jeb Dunnuck 96 - 98 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 96 - 98 J.M. Quarin 97 Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 97 Alexandre Ma 95 - 97 L. Perrotti-Brown 95-97+ RVF 95 - 97 Decanter 96 Vinous – N. Martin 94 - 96 Bettane & Desseauve 94 - 95 Jane Anson 94 Jancis Robinson 16.5+

J. Suckling 97 Alexandre Ma 96 Decanter 96 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 94 - 96 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 95 Wine spec 95 L. Perrotti-Brown 94+ Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 94 Vinous – N. Martin 93 Vinous – A. Galloni 90-93 Jancis Robinson 17+

J.M. Quarin 100 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 98 - 100 Vinous – A. Galloni 98 Alexandre Ma 97 J. Suckling 97 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 97+ Bettane & Desseauve 96-97 Decanter 96 Wine spec 96 Vinous – N. Martin 95 Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 95 Jancis Robinson 16.5

Alexandre Ma 93 Wine spec 91 Jeb Dunnuck 90 Vinous – N. Martin 90 Jancis Robinson 16

J.M. Quarin 96 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 94 - 96 Vinous – A. Galloni 93-96 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 95 Les Echos - B. Burtschy 94 - 95 Alexandre Ma 94 Decanter 94 J. Suckling 94 Jeb Dunnuck 92 - 94 L. Perrotti-Brown 93+ Vinous – N. Martin 93 Wine spec 93 Jancis Robinson 16.5

RVI 100 Terre de Vins 99 - 100 Y. Beck 99 Alexandre Ma 98 J. Suckling 98 Wine Advocate – W. Kelley 98 Les Echos - B. Burtschy 97-98 Le Figaro 96 - 98 RVF 96 - 98 The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 96-98 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 96 - 98 Decanter 97 J.M. Quarin 97 Jeb Dunnuck 97 Vinous – A. Galloni 97 Jane Anson 96 Bettane & Desseauve 95 - 96 Vinous – N. Martin 95 Jancis Robinson 17.5

Jeb Dunnuck 100 Anthocyanes - Y. Castaing 98-100 Wine Cellar Insider - J. Leve 98 - 100 Alexandre Ma 98 J. Suckling 97-98 Vinous – A. Galloni 95-98 Bettane & Desseauve 96 - 97 Decanter 96 J.M. Quarin 96 L. Perrotti-Brown 96+ The Wine Ind. - L. Perrotti 96 Les Echos - B. Burtschy 94 - 96 Vinous – N. Martin 94 Wine spec 93 Jancis Robinson 16